• Overcast
  • 64°
    Overcast

sponsored by Edina Realty

  • Comment

Ryan outlines his budget that will hurt poor

Posted: April 5, 2012 - 5:41pm

Paul Ryan, outlining his latest budget proposal in the House TV studio Tuesday morning, said the policies of the Republican presidential nominees “perfectly jibe” with his plan, which slashes the safety net to pay for tax cuts mostly for wealthy Americans.

“Do you wholeheartedly believe they will accept your budget?” NBC’s Luke Russert called from the audience.

“Absolutely,” the House Budget Committee chairman replied without hesitation. “I’m confident.”

Makes perfect sense, in a way. Mitt Romney, the likely Republican nominee, is on record as saying, “I’m not concerned about the very poor.” And Ryan has just written a budget that supports Romney’s boast.

Ryan would cut $770 billion over 10 years from Medicaid and other health programs for the poor, compared with President Obama’s budget. He takes an additional $205 billion from Medicare, $1.6 trillion from the Obama health-care legislation and $1.9 trillion from a category simply labeled “other mandatory.” Pressed to explain this magic asterisk, Ryan allowed that the bulk of those “other mandatory” cuts come from food stamps, welfare, federal employee pensions and support for farmers.

Taken together, Ryan would cut spending on such programs by $5.3 trillion, much of which currently goes to the have-nots. He would then give that money to America’s haves: some $4.3 trillion in tax cuts, compared with current policies, according to Citizens for Tax Justice.

Ryan’s justification was straight out of Dickens. He wants to improve the moral fiber of the poor. There is, he told the audience at the conservative American Enterprise Institute later Tuesday, an “insidious moral tipping point, and I think the president is accelerating this.” Too many Americans, he said, are receiving more from the government than they pay in taxes.

After recalling his family’s immigration from Ireland generations ago, and his belief in the virtue of people who “pull themselves up by the bootstraps,” Ryan warned that a generous safety net “lulls able-bodied people into lives of complacency and dependency, which drains them of their very will and incentive to make the most of their lives. It’s demeaning.”

How very kind: To protect poor Americans from being demeaned, Ryan is cutting their anti-poverty programs and using the proceeds to give the wealthiest Americans a six-figure tax cut.

Ryan’s budget outline omits specifics about how much he would take from programs. Instead, it provided a string of Orwellian euphemisms. The budget “repairs the safety net” by allowing the states to award public assistance to fewer people — “those who need it most.” Financial aid for college would be slashed — er, “put on a sustainable funding path.” And the Ryan plan would give workers “the tools to thrive in the 21st century” — by killing off various job-training programs.

Ryan would cut Medicaid by a third and ship the remnants to state governments to handle. Or, as the congressman described it: “We also propose to strengthen Medicaid by empowering our states.”

When Ryan released his first budget after becoming committee chairman last year, much of the attention focused on his plans to turn Medicare into a private insurance program. He hasn’t backed away from that, but now he’s making a bolder assault on a full range of social programs.

The shame of this is Ryan once again missed an opportunity to bring some responsible behavior to the capital’s perennial budget fights. He pointed out, correctly, that Senate Democrats have failed for years to produce a budget. He accurately observed that Obama’s budget does little to resolve the debt crisis. And he is right that Medicare and other social programs will collapse if nothing is done to change their revenue-payment structure.

But instead of using the savings from social programs to pay off what he calls a “mountain of debt,” Ryan dishes out tax cuts; the federal debt would continue to grow, by $4 trillion, over his 10-year plan, and the federal budget would remain in deficit.

Such a coupling — tax cuts that disproportionately help the rich and spending cuts that overwhelmingly hurt the poor — makes Ryan’s budget a political loser. His patronizing justification — that he is cutting support for the poor and the old in order to help them — adds insult. “If we have a debt crisis, then the people who get hurt the first and the worst are the poor and the elderly,” he reasoned.

And Ryan thinks the eventual Republican presidential nominee will campaign on this plan? “I’ve spoken to all these guys,” Ryan assured reporters, “and they believe that we are heading in the right direction.”

This explains a lot about the Republicans’ difficulty.

  • Comment

Comments (11)

Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
mission
306
Points
mission 04/06/12 - 03:47 pm
5
5

The Republican Platform:

"I’m not concerned about the very poor.”

(Mitt Romney, the presumtive Republican candidate for President of the United States)
----------------------------
> "Cut $770 billion over 10 years from Medicaid and other health programs for the poor"
> "Cut an additional $205 billion from Medicare, $1.6 trillion from existing legislation and $1.9 trillion from 'other cuts', including food stamps, welfare, federal employee pensions and support for farmers."
> The "savings" would then be used to give $4.3 trillion in tax cuts to the wealthy. Which, according to the Republicans, will "improve the moral fiber of the poor".
(The "program" of Paul Ryan, the Republican fiscal guru.)
-----------------------------------------------
Marie Antoinette never said "Let them eat cake" with respect to the poor, the hungry and the sick, but it's now the motto of the Republican party.

lakelander
708
Points
lakelander 04/06/12 - 05:41 pm
3
5

cuts to Medicaid

Will swamp our Emergency Rooms. Not smart.

tripwire3
4809
Points
tripwire3 04/06/12 - 05:58 pm
6
7

Mission

Per Romney's statement that you quote, what was the statement before and the statement after? Can you tell us anything about the larger context? Anything?

Better, I suppose, to spend billions subsidizing failed green projects and then blame the previous administration for our economic woes. And when that doesn't work, you throw temper tantrums.

You can say what you want about Romney (and I just might agree with you) but the current occupant of the White House is in way over his head. I hope the Dems can do better than him next time around. At least make it fun. Come to think of it, Joe Biden might bring some hilarity to the race. You got any other ideas?

Fair n Balanced
40535
Points
Fair n Balanced 04/06/12 - 06:20 pm
5
7

I've seen a lot of

"very poor people" that live higher off the hog than me and have a lot of pleasure time without working. Are you one of those, Mission?

georgegalt
284
Points
georgegalt 04/06/12 - 08:02 pm
6
4

therein lies the problem

FnB, you say "I've seen a lot of "very poor people" that live higher off the hog than me and have a lot of pleasure time without working."- can't help but detect some envy in that statement.

If you see life thru envious eyes, you'll never be satisfied with your own. As they say, misery loves company, and so it seems your envy of the poor drives your political ideology.

If you truly feel the poor have it better than yourself, why not give up your job and become poor? No one is stopping you.

itterditter
5227
Points
itterditter 04/06/12 - 09:20 pm
7
3

He envies everyone

Union members, teachers, poor people....FNB is one little unhappy man

Fair n Balanced
40535
Points
Fair n Balanced 04/06/12 - 10:05 pm
4
5

Actually I'm very happy and

probably way better off than many of you heel-nippers. I don't envy the hustlers that rob our system but I don't like the fact that they Hog the money that Really Needy people could use.
I have to say that I believe that a few posters on here are using a lot of free equipment to attack a lot of working taxpayers. Your brother and his other brother itter have good reason. Happy Easter to you Too and best wishes to All.

P.S.
I was fishing and caught both of you.

RichRule peasantsdrool
73
Points
RichRule peasantsdrool 04/07/12 - 08:03 am
3
5

Oh boo-hoo, the poor are going to suffer,

oh sniff, sniff. Cue the crying child and the melancholy music! I hardly see envy in the eyes of FNB, nor in the eyes of those with common sense, unlike the liberals, who just show common. There comes a point of no more free ride. How many, who are riding the rails of the life of leisure on someone elses dime, really need what they are getting? Welfare, food stamps, free cell phones, daycare assistance, free lunches, extended unemployment, etc...And before anyone says that Republicans are also claiming some of these things, this isn't about party. This is about fiscal responsibility, and curbing fraud.

walleyehunter
927
Points
walleyehunter 04/07/12 - 10:47 am
2
4

What happens

when an area 5th grade teacher is explaining to his class that this is the point in their young lives that they should start to think about what type of job that they may want when they become adults and a student raises his hand and says " I don't need a job because the government will take care of me just like they do for my mom and dad" ? This is the type of attitude that an increasingly vast number of people in this country have. Does the teacher tell this student that he is right and that "the government" owes it to him and his family to be able to continue to take all that they can get from others? Or, should he be able to tell the student that if he follows the true American dream and gets a good education and works hard he will have a better life, than living off someone elses hard work? With the current thought being presented by this administration and the major media outlets, the kid is lead to believe that he is living the dream now. Very sad.

mission
306
Points
mission 04/07/12 - 12:58 pm
3
2

Oh Goody -- another fairy

Oh Goody -- another fairy tale from 'walleyehunter' :

A fictitious 5th grade teacher...
Gives a fictitious lecture...
To a fictitious class of students...
One of the fictitious students raises his hand and says:
"I don't need a job because the government will take care of me."

And, based on this fabricated tripe, 'walleyehunter' concludes that "This is the type of attitude that an increasingly vast number of people in this
country have."

Who, exactly, counted that "vast number of people".
Be sure to write again when the bottle is empty.

walleyehunter
927
Points
walleyehunter 04/07/12 - 01:20 pm
2
2

When the truth

hits you in the face mission, does it hurt. This was not a fairy tail. Of course you will not understand that so what's the use. What I stated was an actual conversation that took place in a classroom in a nearby town.
The "vast number of people" are the 49% of the people that pay absolutly nothing in taxes and recieve money back from the rest of us tax payers, for whatever reason they have for not becoming one of the productive taxpayers. Maybe that is because of people like you that think that for some reason you are owed something because someone else has choosen to work and succeed. To deny that this is taking place in classrooms across the country is to your peril.

Back to Top

Spotted

Please Note: You may have disabled JavaScript and/or CSS. Although this news content will be accessible, certain functionality is unavailable.

Skip to News

« back

next »

  • title http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543878/ http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543873/ http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543868/
  • title http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543863/ http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543858/ http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543848/
  • title
Pillager K-2nd Track & Field Day

CONTACT US

  • Switchboard 218-829-4705
  • Report News 218-855-5860
  • Advertising 218-855-5835
  • Classifieds 218-855-5898
  • Circulation 218-855-5897
  • View the Staff Directory
  • or Send feedback

ADVERTISING

SUBSCRIBER SERVICES

SOCIAL NETWORKING