WASHINGTON — It is a rare day when Al Sharpton emerges as the voice of sagacity, but when Newt Gingrich has the microphone, all things are possible.
Just four weeks out from the Iowa caucuses, and swinging like a trapeze artist over the heads of his fellow Republican contenders, Gingrich has done what everyone knew he would — said something mind-blowingly wrong. Not just wrong as in incorrect, but off-the-charts insensitive, insulting and, most important, Out. Of. Touch.
He might as well have wrapped his remarks in a Tiffany’s box and handed them to Mitt Romney, who could exhale for a moment. Or to Sharpton, who finally had a justifiable excuse for outrage and scorched the earth beneath Gingrich’s feet on his MSNBC show.
Gingrich’s big idea was that kids from poor neighborhoods should work janitorial jobs at school in order to learn a work ethic. His argument was that poor kids who live in housing projects don’t see people working and therefore “literally have no habit of showing up on Monday.” Instead, they gravitate toward, you know, pimping and prostitution.
So much for the big tent. So much for diversity. Sayonara African-American vote. Hasta la vista, Paco y Maria. In one flick of the tongue, Gingrich managed to alienate all those undocumented workers he winked at a couple of weeks ago when he telegraphed during a debate that 11 million illegal immigrants would not be deported during a Gingrich presidency.
The former speaker’s fumble is precisely what some Republicans have feared and others have breathlessly anticipated. The Washington Wager was whether Gingrich could make it four weeks without self-immolating before Iowa. Or would he find himself so irresistible that he just had to express himself?
Voila.
Gingrich backpedaled, saying he hadn’t meant the “working poor,” which, of course, leaves all those shiftless folks in the projects who’d rather peddle drugs and their girlfriends than get honest work as janitors. To cap things off, just in case anyone was still confused, Gingrich found fellowship with Donald Trump, who not only endorsed the idea, but agreed to help Gingrich create a program much like “The Apprentice,” where poor kids can seek to emulate The Donald. Don’t be poor, be rich like me! Hair optional.
We ask much of our candidates, perhaps too much. With such high-definition exposure over such a long period, everyone is bound to trip, or utter the irretrievably dumb thing. On the other hand, a person’s true character is often revealed with time. As with any courtship, one can hold a pose only so long.
For Republicans, the pose of Everyman has rarely been a good fit and Gingrich’s remarks may confirm more than they reveal. An echo of the decades-ago, welfare-queen stereotype, Gingrich’s comments feed an increasingly prevalent GOP meme that the jobless are somehow responsible for their plight. Before bowing out, Herman Cain averred that people who aren’t rich or employed have only themselves to blame. A panelist at a recent debate in New York between devotees of economists Friedrich Hayek and John Maynard Keynes said Hayek would advise protesters to “occupy a job.”
If only it were so simple.
Republicans have always been wedded to the idea that Americans, given opportunity, can pull themselves up by the bootstraps. In fact, most people subscribe to this very-American narrative to varying degrees. But missing from the vision of the coldest eye is acknowledgement that sometimes people have no boots.
With a degree of charity not apparent in Gingrich’s remarks, one can hypothesize about what he may have meant, such as perhaps that one can only imagine becoming what one has seen. How does a child who has never witnessed a doctor or lawyer in his everyday world imagine himself as one? Alas, Gingrich didn’t start there.
Tough times call for tough solutions, but singling out poor children is one of those random thousand-ideas-a-minute that should have gone directly into the right brain’s shredder. A better idea might have taken its place. Here’s one for the hopper: Let all children volunteer to contribute to their school’s upkeep in exchange for vouchers redeemable for privileges that school kids value. Think of it as an experiment in capitalism (work for reward) and self-esteem building (status through achievement).
It’s a capital idea both Democrats and Republicans could love. For fun, we could tax the vouchers and give a small share of earned privileges to those who chose not to participate. Talk about an education.



Comments (19)
Add commentGingrich is right on this
Gingrich is right on this one.
There are whole segments of the population who don't know anyone who works and have never held a job.
I agree, Fish.
I agree, Fish.
Fish
Yes, you are absolutly right!
she is right
you can NOT expect diversity to work when all they have to do is find a female with a kid on welfare and "bingo" a free ride! work-not in 8 or 9 generations,and they won't stay in school to learn anything-nice future. you are correct newt but the food stamp people rule!
Moonhawk - Are you talking
Moonhawk - Are you talking about the "babies daddy's" that take no responsibility for their children?
"There are whole segments of
"There are whole segments of the population who don't know anyone who works and have never held a job."
I'm guessing you've laid this out as a decoy to see how many conservatives would take the bait and appear as foolish as Gingrich, fish. If this is not the case, which "whole segments of the population" are you referring to? There is only one "segment" that meets the criteria and that would be 'infants under the approximate age of 2'.
weren't 'jobs' programs for poor young workers cut?
I'm all for jobs programs but what I visualized is throwing out the (union?) custodians and replacing them with poor, black welfare kids scrubbing toilets. We used to call that slavery. Creating a work ethic is a good thing. Job training, apprenticeships,vocational education so one can find a job, etc.
The way Newt worded it left a really bad smell.
Of course Newt is known for doing that - which is what terrifies the GOP leadership, that he'll be the endorsed candidate.
Trump is all about PR and promoting himself. Could he help more than 10 children that has he proposed apprenticeship for,
if he's really serious?
mnsnowda
"Of course Newt is known for doing that - which is what terrifies the GOP leadership, that he'll be the endorsed candidate."
And the other GOP candidates are afraid they, themselves, will be the object of his nasty tongue. Just look at how he was their buddy during the first debate and is now Mr. "I am going to be the choice." It is going to get interesting.
Actually I wasn't baiting the
Actually I wasn't baiting the cons. I know someone who works in social services in a large metro system and that person told me they have clients who are 4th generation welfare recipients and don't know a single person who works. That's just plain wrong.
What chance do they have of holding down a job where they have to show up at 8 and stay until 5 M-F?
It's not a race issue because people of all races are found in that segment.
This is why I'm v0ting f0r
This is why I'm v0ting f0r Newt! Obama lied and is still spewing pp fr0m his m0uth, I want a President wh0 d0esnt just run his m0uth with g00d speeches and n0 perf0rmance like we have in 0ffice n0w. Get the m0nkey 0ut 0f the cage he keeps eating all the bananas and charging them t0 us. Newt tells the truth, anniej0e if y0u seri0usly want t0 drink the bama-aid, I invite y0u t0 m0ve in with him after we are finally liberated from his socialist ideals!
socialist ideas?
As a far left voter, until just recently I was furious at Obama for going to the middle
and trying to negotiate with the right-wingers. Only recently has he found his voice and
is starting to speak for the 99%. The GOP has no interest in moving this country forward,
their only concern is making sure we are unhealthy so Obama will not get a 2nd term.
Well good luck that that, the GOP blew it's chance in 2012 by running crazy candidates and
the few sane ones are barely being looked at. I find this incredibly amusing and even shocking.
Those of you who think Obama is Kenyan or Socialist need to get a grip.
And I'm really tired of the monkey comments. That's really distasteful and even racist.
As much as I disliked GWB and what he did to tank this country (he inherited a surplus from Clinton)
I did not think he was anti-American. I thought he was stupid most of the time, but the racist stuff
that comes out regarding Obama really ticks me off. Then the GOP denies this.
I keep trying to convince myself that most of the anger toward Obama is not racist,
but, I am more and more convinced that it is.
Please keep supporting Newt. The Democrats are cheering and they hope he IS the endorsed candidate. REALLY.
what minnesnowda is really scared of:
"I visualized is throwing out the (union?) custodians and replacing them with poor, black welfare kids scrubbing toilets"
Those kids'll prolly do a better job for half the money. Unions hate real workers
jomammy,
Maybe you should try getting a real job other than spewing garbage (but then most employers want people with intelligence, not mental cases).
Not afraid of anything, really just relishing
the GOP chaos I am seeing lately.
Young workers would still need supervision and highly skilled workers can't be replaced
by those with few skills.
By the way I have never been in a union. I am fortunate to have worked for companies
that were ethical and fair. I have witnessed my friends being jerked around by their
companies and of course companies eager to toss out workers once they achieve a certain
pay level. It is too bad workers need protection like that, but many do.
sad
When insipid comments are all they've got, they know they are losing. And it is easy to make racist and anti-union remarks anonymously. I wonder why the Dispatch allows these remarks. Maybe they think it sells papers...or whatever is being advertised on this page. I had to look...Kitchen aid coffee pots. Yep, we are all going to buy one after reading this stuff. Maybe they should put a mouthwash ad on the political pages instead.
Good post, minnesnowda
We can always count on your sane replies.
Maybe I'm missing a post or
Maybe I'm missing a post or two, but the only racism I see on here is from Snowda.
I'm sure she doesn't even realize she's playing that card though.
Yeah,
you're a couple of posts short.
perhaps wolfg needs this spelled out more clearly??
This is why I'm v0ting f0r Newt!
By lamigra | 12/07/11 - 07:00 pm
This is why I'm v0ting f0r Newt! Obama lied and is still spewing pp fr0m his m0uth, I want a President wh0 d0esnt just run his m0uth with g00d speeches and n0 perf0rmance like we have in 0ffice n0w. Get the m0nkey 0ut 0f the cage he keeps eating all the bananas and charging them t0 us.
Boston Police Officer/National Guardsman Fired for Calling Gates, “banana-eating jungle monkey”: A Historical Perspective
Justin Barrett, a Boston police overseer and solider in the National Guard, recently sent a mass e-mail to his colleagues referring to Harvard professor Henry Louis Gates Jr. as a “banana-eating jungle monkey”. Not that we needed any confirmation that the enforcers of the state’s repressive agenda were inherently racist (Gates’ arrest in an of itself is evidence of this) but this particular instance resurrects a scathing legacy racist iconography that I feel needs further investigation. That, of course being, Black man = monkey.
Sharpton should be happy
After listening to what Newt said why would Sharpy be upset? Janitors in schools are union employees with health insurance, vacation and sick pay. 2080 at least in a year. whats to complaine about. Oh thas right they have to WORK for it and why when they can sit back and collect a check.
and
If a not so poor kid wanted to do the janitorial aide job, then what? Would it be fair to only have the poor working at the schools? This would be a nightmare to manage and was only an attempt to pander to the part of the public who like to slam those on welfare. This is what Newt likes to do. Next week, another issue.
But Romney's Iowa ad about Newt's wives is quite unlike my impressions of Mitt. Wait until Newt comes raging back about this. Such fun.