Round and round they go, the city of Brainerd is about ready to introduce drivers and the community to roundabouts following the completion of the College Drive project, tentatively set for Oct. 26.
But why roundabouts? Brainerd City Engineer Jeff Hulsether said the decision was based primarily on safety.
“The arguments in favor of roundabouts are so overwhelming,” said Hulsether about bringing roundabouts to the area. “The safety, capacity and access provided by roundabouts was the perfect solution on College Drive and is being found to be the right solution in communities all over the state.
“As of last fall, there were over 180 roundabouts either constructed, being constructed, designed, planned or considered and that number will continue to grow.
“They will become very commonplace and more the norm than the exception.”
Hulsether added that concerns from citizens are understandable, and his biggest concern will be with the first snowfall as discussions about plowing have been brought up.
Hulsether gave his own advice for anyone hesitant to go through the new road additions.
“My advice for driving roundabouts is to simply slow down and follow the rules,” he said, adding the city is planning a ribbon cutting at 10 a.m. on Oct. 26 on the bridge deck. “First, before entering the roundabout be aware of the lane assignments which are the same as any other four lane road. If you plan to turn left or make a u-turn you should be in the left lane. If you plan to make a right turn, use the right lane. If you plan to go straight, you can use either lane. Next, watch for pedestrians crossing at the roundabouts and yield to anyone in the roundabout to your left.”
For further explanation, the Dispatch spoke with Andrew Plowman, transportation project manager and roundabout expert at WSB and Associates, Inc., the city’s consultant on the College Drive project, Plowman included the following explanations:
What is a roundabout?
According to Plowman, it’s a circulatory intersection in which motorists in the circulating lane have the right of way over entering vehicles.
■ Driving Tips
1. Yield to pedestrians in the crosswalk.
2. Choose the correct lane approaching the roundabout. Left lane is for left turners, right lane is for right turners. The through movement can be made from both lanes.
3. Yield to vehicles in the circulating lanes (note, there may be more than one circulating lane). Yield does not mean merge. When you see a gap, you may enter the roundabout.
4. Do not stop in the circulating lane. Do not change lanes within the circle.
5. If an emergency vehicle is near and you are within the circulatory lanes, continue through the roundabout and pull over once you exit the roundabout provided there is adequate space for the emergency vehicle to pass you.
6. Give large trucks adequate space to maneuver through the roundabout. The roundabouts include a truck apron (red concrete area), adjacent to the central island, which allows trucks to track upon when maneuvering through the roundabout. The truck apron is not to be used by passenger vehicles.
7. All traffic should travel counter-clockwise through the roundabout. It is dangerous to travel through in the opposite direction.
8. Travel cautiously through the roundabout. You may know how to travel through the roundabout, but other motorists might have trouble the first few times.
9. Keep in mind, roundabouts provide a great opportunity to make a U-turn to access areas that may be blocked by a median. Be sure to enter the left lane for this move, and go all the way around the roundabout when making the U-turn.
10. Never change lanes within the roundabout and do not make a left turn from the right lane. The interior motorist may be making the thru movement.
Although over 3,400 roundabouts have been constructed in the United States since 1990, much of the public still has a difficult time embracing the benefits of the relatively new type of intersection. Below is a list of some of the key benefits to roundabouts over other types of intersection control.
■ Roundabout Benefits:
• Improves safety — Intersections converted to roundabouts from a stop controlled or signalized configuration have shown the following reduction in collisions:
• A 37 percent reduction in overall collisions
• A 73 percent reduction in collisions which result in an injury.
• A 90 percent reduction in collisions which result in fatality.
The reasons for the improved safety include low travel speeds and reduced conflict points. Drivers are required to slow down prior to entering the roundabout, simply due to the geometry. Typically, speeds entering the roundabout are between 15 and 20 mph.
The reasons for the improved safety are the following:
• Low Travel Speeds – drivers are required to slow down prior to entering the roundabout due to the geometry of the roundabout. Typically, speeds entering the roundabout are between 15 and 20 mph. The collisions that may occur are sideswipe type crashes that are not severe like 90 degree (T-bone) type crashes that are typical at signalized and stop controlled intersections
• Reduced Conflict Points – There are 32 potential conflict points at a standard signalized or stop controlled intersection. The corresponding number of conflict points at a roundabout is eight. In addition, there are no left turn conflict points as all traffic is traversing in the same direction around the roundabout.
• Reduce Delay, Improve Traffic Flow: Roundabouts promote a continuous flow of traffic. At a signal, drivers are required to wait for a green light to enter the intersection. At a stop controlled intersection, traffic is required to come to a complete stop whereas traffic is only required to yield at a roundabout. At a side-street stop controlled intersection, motorists are required to find a gap which is more difficult with the higher speeds than what exists at a roundabout. This results in some motorists taking chances to enter the intersection.
Studies by Kansas State University measured traffic flow at intersections before and after conversion to roundabouts. In each case, installing a roundabout led to a 20 percent reduction in delays.
• Less Right of Way Required: Although a roundabout may require more land at the intersection itself than a signalized intersection, roundabouts often require less space leading to the intersection. This is because signalized and stop controlled intersections require long storage space for left and right turn lanes.
• Reduction in Emissions and Fuel Consumption: Due to the continuous flow and decrease in vehicle idling, roundabouts are shown to reduce carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide emissions as well creating a reduction in fuel consumption.
• Aesthetics: The central island and splitter islands allow for landscaping. This provides the opportunity to create a gateway for a community. The landscaping can also create an aesthetic division between commercial and residential areas.
Currently, the roundabouts are open to traffic, to some extent. Much of the landscaping will be placed in the spring, which will cause some lane closures for the contractor to access the central island and splitter islands.
Additional sources regarding roundabouts can be found at the following websites:
• www.dot.state.mn.us/research/how-about-a-roundabout-video+brochure.html
• www.dot.state.mn.us/roundabouts/
• www.co.washington.mn.us/info_for_residents/transportation_division/round...
JESSI PIERCE, staff writer, may be reached at 855-5859 or jessi.pierce@brainerddispatch.com. Follow her on Twitter at www.twitter.com/jessi_pierce (@jessi_pierce).



Comments (39)
Add commentAnderson Brothers
Thank you for doing such an amazing job on this project. It is fresh, clean and beautiful. And while you're finishing up, if you see anyone going the wrong way in the roundabouts, most likely they're Republicons....don't try and stop them, they like to make fools of themselves...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Tdu4uKSZ3M
Why do you have to bring
Why do you have to bring politics into this?
Pedestrians in danger near Roundabouts
This was a topic the article avoided--drivers have a harder time detecting and avoiding pedestrians in roundabouts. I'd suggest crossing somewhere else except I think there aren't many of them anymore. People don't yet know how to drive in these things, particularly a two lane one when traffic is heavy--and their focus and mind will be on just navigating their car so they can turn where they want to.
I would use extra caution and even try to avoid crossing at a roundabout period for some months after these things open.
Groovy...Coming to Brainerd for MEA...Some Europe...
'92 Chevy Van - 350 Cubic Inches American V8, Fuel Injected...
Heavier Corvette stuff...
Glass Pack Muffler (3 footer)...Old School...And sounds nice, even at 183,000 miles yet...
However...Time to Share...
Memories of Europe...Round A Bouts...
Reliving losing the Gas Pedal with a VW Rental Van in the Netherlands, Haarlem, and getting lost in the Round About...
I didn't get hit, and folks were super understanding...
All the while I'm belting out American Slang in Holland...
Round A Bouts are Cool...And Safe...
Just wait and see....
I understand the need for something and I'm thinking it may work at the Fourth Street intersection.....what I'm confused about is the second one to the west, especially when there is still additional entrance to college parking lot?!? And then NOTHING....no lights only 4-way stop (at least as of last week when I drove through) at the College Drive/CR48 intersection?!?! Just like Olive Garden...I will avoid until all the fuse and craziness is over.....good luck Brainerd drivers!!
Well since the city
Street Dept misunderstood that memo that was supposed to go to the school from michelle o about no salt in the food so they only put 1 cup of salt per 1 yard of sand. It is going to be funny to watch when it is slippery out.
BTW I bet the county got that same memo. They dont use much salt either. Just lots of sand. Baxter & MNDOT know how to keep rd's clear.
MEA Week
Hey scribbles, what's MEA week. Is that where 3 teachers go to school and the other 79,997 rip off the taxpayers for a free vacation and come to Brainerd Lakes Area to run their jet skis, atvs etc and tear up the area where the rest of us try to live. It takes 2 weeks for the fish and deer to come back out of hiding after MEA week is over.
Charlie...A repreave...
A Fall Event...
Capture the Cash Flow coming...
Economic Stimulus, yes...
We choose Brainerd...
We don't choose Florida...
Which one do you choose...
Brainerd...Florida...
Your choice for economic enhancement...
i cant wait for the first semi or bus to get stuck
Its coming, they are too small. A semi is going to squash a car for sure. They will drive over the hood or worse.
I took my boat through there the other day. I have a 20 foot boat so the trailer/boat combo is somewhere around 25 feet and it wasnt an easy fit.
Those semis delivering food to the college are going to have tons of fun.
This is the worst design ever. Roundabout is one thing, too small of a roundabout is another, 3 roundabouts too small IDIOTS.
By the way, can you say traffic jams when you have a roundabout too close to a traffic light? Thats what you are going to have.
Congratulations to the group of idiots that designed this...mark my words, HUGE CHANGES coming in the near future
Don't forget...
the stoplights at the top of the hill by the High School. First icy rain day I'm going to bring a sandwich and video camera to watch the spin outs trying to climb the hill.
LLR,
There should be amusement all the way from Quince to Highland Scenic, and the spectators can sit on those glorious new retaining walls below the Vo-Tech building.. Everyone knows there's going to be accidents, let's just pray no one gets seriously hurt or killed.
Scribbles-A teacher
This is the first time I have ever heard the words teacher and economic enhancement in the same sentence. Try economic disaster and teacher in the same sentence and you will be talking reality. Here is economic enhancement: take 80,000 teachers, let them keep their current salaries, take their union dues and give it back to the taxpayers instead of some union boss, now that's economic enhancement and teacher used in the same sentence. Take two hours wages per month (union dues) times 80,000 teachers, assuming $60 per teacher, and you and I both know that's low, give it back to the taxpayers, and that makes $4million, 8oo thousand dollars per month back into the economy. Now that's what I call economic stimulus. The only thing lost would be your right to keep your job for substandard performance and Tommy Dooher would have to find a teaching job. ECONOMIC STIMULUS 101. And that's only in Minnesota. Bye the way, Florida would be a better place for you to go. You would be right at home with Goofy and Mickey Mouse. Sorry scribbles, your crayons don't write very well on my blackboard. PS: Take little Johnny Ward with you.
Charlie M and smartguy
You two should get together
Thanks Itter
I learned all that from a real teacher, back in 1st grade, 60 years ago.
Roundabouts-you ain't seen nuttin yet
MNDOT is now building something called a "DIAMOND" rather than a roundabout. Read about it the other day. Don't remember where. What will this nightmare look like.????? Anyone else heard about this yet.
Don't forget the money blown on this atrocity
Anyone remember the price tag for this debacle. Seems to me I remember that there were bid's to fix the road up and make it right for under a million, but NOOOOOO! The city of Brainerd thought it a good idea instead to blow more than 7 million on this logistical disaster.
It is too small, it's dumb and Americans don't drive like they do in Europe where they do sort of work. You gotta remember in Europe they're banging into and bouncing off each other all over all the time and it's no big deal. (The reality is they are better drivers than Americans, hence why they don't want any of us on the Autobahn).
All the studies, survey's and research they want to shove down our throats will not convince anyone with a half a brain in their head that this thing is anything but a nightmare.
It will be a hoot to get ring side seats at the 'Ring Road Show' and watch all the accidents.
As far as people getting stuck on the hills, that probably won't be any big deal as they will have 2 inches of salt on a 1/2 inch of snow just like MNDOT does every time it gets cloudy out.
Don't thank dithers, charlie.
He's a true friend and sponser for smartguy AKA "teacher's union thug".
oh no, more teacher envy.
oh no, more teacher envy. You guys are about as original and as ideologically narrowed as the Guy Green Gang. Sounds like Charlie had a bad experience in school. Sorry to hear that. I do give some credit to FNB, though. I guess beinbg labeled a "union thug" is a tad less tasteless than being labeled as a "dirtbag". Small steps I guess.
I admit that I don't
I admit that I don't understand roundabouts. My question is, what are they referring to when they say a left turn on it? Is it not one way travel, making a left turn would be into the center divider wouldn't it?
Not so Male Michele
I couldn't imagine dealing with the spawn of this community for 9 months. Male Michele, you should go shadow Smartguy for a couple of days...ya think ya got the sack for it????? Judging by your posts, you would get eaten alive....better yet, go shadow a middle school or elementary teacher...let me know when ya need a lawyer when you slap a kid for telling you to f-off....slap, slap, slap
smartguy,
I wanted to use an almost equal but not as graphic name this time as I am becoming more polished in my attacks.
Unlike you weird friend, dithers, that continues to act like he/she needs some special education.
Have a nice evening though SG, you are a worthy opponent.
I'm not an opponent. Just
I'm not an opponent. Just another guy who doesn;t subscribe to your world view. Good night
Bring-em on
FNB, Thanks for the tip. As for union thug, bring em on. I eat em for breakfast. Hey smart guy. I can understand why you would think that learning something in school would be a bad experience, especially in todays schools. Learning anything from todays teachers is a bad experience. As for the Guy Green Gang, I'm a member. Only intelligent people can belong. You're out of luck. I'm Guy Greens bouncer. As a smart man once said: "Go ahead punk, make my day."
Amusing to read!
As a European I have to admit it hilarious reading these comments against roundabouts!
It is like listening to people who have just been introduced to the wheel for the first time. I have been driving the roundabouts all week and it seems many are avoiding them as way to show their disapproval! We will see if that lasts?
Change was hard for those who liked square wheels when the round ones where introduced, so I suppose it will be the same in this instance!
Keep bringing the entertainment in this forum please, please, please!!!
Roundabouts for dummies: Look left, nothing coming? Go! If something is coming, stop, wait, then go! Simple as....
But, SG that makes you an opponent.
Are you taking mars/snow, fish, dithers, eye, and the rest of the loonies to the "Million Muppet March"? That sounds right up your alley.
Hey Smart Guy, it's a trap.
SG was marching a bunch of libs through the desert. He was the commander. From behind a sand dune came a sound "one conservative can whoop 10 libs". So SG sent 10 libs over to take out the Conservative. None came back. Pretty soon, SG heard another sound from behind the sand dune; "one conservative can whoop 100 libs." He then sent 100 libs to take out the Conservative. None came back. Soon, he heard another voice from behind the sand dune; "one conservative can take out 1000 libs." SG was pretty mad by this time so he sent 1000 libs to take out the conservative behind the sand dune. All hell broke loose. Pretty soon 1 lib came crawling from over the sand dune. He hollered back to SG. Don't send anymore. It's a trap. There are two of them.
Oh no, Charlie is speaking in
Oh no, Charlie is speaking in tongues now.
That won't go over so well with the social conservative segment of the Guy Green Blackshirts. Are there any priests qualified to do an excorcism in our small town?
Two questions:
1. Do you take meds?
2. Are you off of them?
Wow! Charlie you have outdone
Wow! Charlie you have outdone yourself. Have you ever heard this saying? It is better to remain quiet and let people think you are a fool, than to open it and remove all doubt.
Wood Pile Larry
Well, look what just crawled out from under the woodpile. Did SG call you for assistance. He's been taking quite a beating today. Well motley, take your best shot. Show us your ignorance.
Larry did that the other day charlie,
when he came after me.