• Overcast
  • 54°
    Overcast

sponsored by Edina Realty

Are unions bad?

In American history the enemy of the union used to be called a Confederate, nowadays they seem more and more to be called Republicans. Is 'union' really such a bad word now in these "United" States?

I've worked in union shops, I've worked in non-union shops. There was always a clear choice when I applied, I never felt I didn't have a 'right to work' living in Minnesota and still don't. I see no reason for our state to adopt laws restricting the abilities unions have in negotiating for employee benefits. I also see no reason someone who benefits from unions shouldn't have to contribute something toward maintaining those benefits.

Some in the Republican party are seemingly attempting to push these anti-union measures because they see unions as a large political contributor for the Democratic party.

If the objection relates to union fees going toward political campaigns, I do concurr on that point, that practice should be discontinued. We should all lobby for congress to adopt common sense political campaign rules which prohibit unions, businesses, corporate entities or groups of any kind whatsoever from funding political parties or campaigns. Eliminate PACs completely. Eliminate inequity from our representation in government which has only seemingly been reinforced by decisions such as the Citizens United supreme court case.

In my opinion Citizens United got it completely wrong: Money is not the same as speech, for if that were the case, not all men are created equal. Following the Citizens United case logic, a billionaire trust fund baby enjoys much, much more freedom of speech than a general laborer who works every day of their life and barely gets by.

A person's union dues going toward a particular political party is just as wrong as a person's purchase of a non-political commodity from a particular store ending up supporting a particular political party. Both injustices must be resolved at the same time though, one can't eliminate just one while leaving the other untethered and unrestrained.

If the union boss, or the corporate CEO, or the laborer wants to support any given party, let them do so as an individual, with their own personal money and shared limitations.

Let our true political power in America be demonstrated with our individual vote, not how much money we can contribute. That way every individual would have an equal say over how we would be governed.

Instead of political parties and candidates running to unions, the Koch brothers or George Soros for funding, force them to gather funding and support directly from 'We the People', everyone they should be representing. Make all political contributions publicly reported and capped at a reasonable level so everyone can clearly see who's giving to whom and how much.

Do that, and we can get unions out of political funding entirely. I'm guessing union dues, 'fair share' contributions, and any trumped up controversy regarding unions would be decreased substantially as a result.

Maybe instead of concentrating on how to further divide America, we can come together and make our shared community a better place for all.

Comments (3)

Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
georgegalt
284
Points
georgegalt 03/18/12 - 12:24 am
2
0

Appreciate your thoughts

Very good points you bring up too.

I could go a few rounds on religion as well, :-) but anyone who will allow me the freedom of my own spiritual beliefs, I will happily support their right to believe in theirs.

I will say I'm not prepared to consider all unions bad because of random examples otherwise. I tend to believe some are good, some could definately be improved upon, some probably are bad, but all would be much better off if we could distance politics from their purview.

Just the same, I like our state how it is now, where some jobs have unions and others don't. If legislation is ever passed which tips the scale one way or the other removing that choice, I fear for the future of our fine state.

shadrack
6967
Points
shadrack 03/20/12 - 09:12 am
2
0

Let's get all the money out of elections

Some good points, George. Unions have certainly made the lives of workers better. Sweat shops, child labor, inequality in pay structure, etc. have all disappeared or at least been reduced. Unions have improved pay and working conditions for all workers.

And Unions lobby for their interests. United they have a bit of power in Minnesota and the nation (though much less power than in the past.) The money unions have available for lobbying is tiny compared to what large corporations spend on lobbying. If we eliminated all lobbying (corporate, union, and other special interests), we'd give our legislatures a fighting chance to do what is right for all their constituents, not just the ones who write big checks. As long as elected officials are receiving big campaign contributions, they will inherently feel responsible and indebted to those contributors. So let's take this a step further. Let's have government financed election campaigns with no other contributions to candidates. Let's give all candidates an equal playing field. Maybe in so doing we'd even get rid of the ridiculous length and expense of current campaigns. Maybe we'd get back to talking honestly about issues instead of using sound bites and propaganda to win elections.

Back to Top

Spotted

Please Note: You may have disabled JavaScript and/or CSS. Although this news content will be accessible, certain functionality is unavailable.

Skip to News

« back

next »

  • title http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543863/ http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543858/ http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543848/
  • title http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543843/ http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543838/ http://spotted.brainerddispatch.com/galleries/543833/
  • title
Montessori Kindergarten Graduation

CONTACT US

  • Switchboard 218-829-4705
  • Report News 218-855-5860
  • Advertising 218-855-5835
  • Classifieds 218-855-5898
  • Circulation 218-855-5897
  • View the Staff Directory
  • or Send feedback

ADVERTISING

SUBSCRIBER SERVICES

SOCIAL NETWORKING